September 8th, 2007

Is Manhunt 2 destroying the reputation of the industry?

Published at 6:00 AM PST

CVG has posted quite an interesting article on whether or not Manhunt 2 is damaging the gaming industry. Elite creator David Braben told CVG that violent games like Manhunt are destroying the reputation of the industry as a whole long-term.

“There have been a few games that have strange ratings like Gears of War (18). That does not make sense to me. Why is it not a 15? Okay, there are some slightly gruesome bodies hanging up in the first section of the game, but this is no more than you’d expect in a 15 film like Alien Vs Predator or The Terminator films.”

“This means that when a more genuine 18 comes along, parents assume it is no worse than Gears of War, and is perhaps why Manhunt 2 was banned, as they felt they could not give it the same rating as Gears.”

“While Manhunt 2 might have brought short term gain to Rockstar, it damages the reputation of the industry as a whole, long term. We do need a strong, consistent rating system, where 18 really means 18, and is enforced, and then it may be more acceptable to make such games, or to bring in an additional rating (as in the US) of Adults Only - which are only sold in very restricted places”

 

Quite a few valid points there. Read the full interview here.